Oh, only about 100% agree.
Actually I'd always go for the XKR in preference to the XK8. I had two XKR convertibles as my daily drivers and a Vanquish as the weekender. The XKR is a whole other animal to the XK8. A very underrated car in my opinion.
It is said, usually in a very quiet voice, that the very latest 5 litre XKR is a better car than the DB9.
I've owned Jags as well. My wife looked at the XKR, XFR, Maser, Bentley and others. Decided on the DB9. It's a real beauty and she couldn't be happier.