Best Battery
If you pick out another battery I would be interested in knowing what you end up with... thanksThanks for asking. No powerful experience, and admittedly more of a "hunch". Hardly scientific. What I do know is that fundamentally the Optima's are different than the conventional lead-acid battery type (which includes the maintenance free, and gel-cell batteries) and they DO have different characteristics.
Perhaps the most "blatant" difference is when we try to program the cars after we have done a pulley upgrade. I happen to really like the completeness of the Ford Racing pulley upgrade kit and we have done quite a few of them this year. The programmer that you get with the Ford Racing kit cautions you never to start loading in a new program onto a partially charged battery. Makes sense. The odd part is that the programmer will check battery voltage and will frequently refuse to load the program into the GT because it thinks the battery is insufficiently charged and might die during the load process. Mind you, these cars typically crank, start, and run fine - you'd never think you had a low-voltage battery. When we test these batteries with a Fluke (known, high quality VOM), we will see static voltages of 11-11.5V. In a "conventional" battery, an 11-11.5V voltage reading would rightfully equate to a low battery. Not so with the Optima as it seems "happy" to live at these lower voltages.
So (and here's the leap), I think the GT's gauge control module is fooled the same way that Ford Racing programmer is fooled. They both have been programmed for conventional battery "traits". When the GT's on-board gauge control module doesn't witness 12v at key-on, it sometime fails to initialize one or more of the gauges correctly. I am much more comfortable to recommend a conventiaonal battery as I trust that the behavior is known.
Again, I'm really glad you asked because my hypothesis has some merit (I think) but is far, far from being proven. I changed the oil on my car this weekend and despite being on a Tender full-time, the battery is noticeably weaker when cranking during the priming procedure. It is time for a new battery and I will likely go to Sears and pay for the current "Sears Best", rather than to go for another Optima.