Drew thanks for chiming in.
Please look at Spirit's post #13 and tell us what you think.
Our dear friend just recently had a misfortune where someone rear ended him and took off so he is going through what all of us hope never happens to us but then again one never knows......
The post was pretty accurate. My experience has shown that most claims involving UM and your vehicle are covered under collision. However, as stated in the post, some states refer back to the um coverage, so carrying a high limit is crucial in those states.
Every state has different insurance laws and not all insurance policies are obviously apples to apples. I have talked to a few owners today and I told them that discussing insurance in a forum is tough, because not everyone carries the same coverage.
You have to ask yourself do you live in the same state, do you carry the same liability/um, or do you have agreed, acv, or stated amount policies? Many consumers do not even see the need to carry um/uim which in some states with high percentages of uninsured motorists, you are asking for trouble. We always say if you are a homeowner, carry at least 100/300 for BI & UM. I am sure many of you have umbrella policies, but for those that do not, it is wise to never dip below that level.
What state you live in makes a huge difference as well. Most states are pro consumer in insurance law, but you never know what a dumb legislator puts into law. Sometimes you get a law that looks pro consumer, but makes it tough on an insurance company to do business, thus you get decreased competition and less insurance choices.
The bottomline, as Bony stated, read the policy! Agreed value is the best policy for collector car owners. Stated value is second best (usually reserved for newer exotics - however we can offer GT owners agreed) and ACV is usually the worst. Although, a good adjuster always makes the difference, but they are a dime a dozen. Most policies come with a table of contents at renewal and it is pretty easy (for the most part - some will question this statement) to find quick answers.
My two cents based on my experience with collector policies only! Hopefully I answered your question somewhat. It is late and I have 10 month old triplets, so my brain is fried by the time they go to bed.