Thanks for all the input guys. I just ordered another Superwinch S5000. Seems that what I was already using was as good as it gets.
The only reason I was considering replacing it with something else is because my first on blew up on me. I have it slightly offset to match the tow hook on the car but the cable was stacking up on one side anyway. I used it probably 10 times before it came apart.
I had loaded a 69 Bronco and noticed the cable was badly stacked on one end of the drum. When I unloaded it by powering out the cable, a loop had somehow formed on the drum and as the loop tried to come off the drum it literally blew the fairlead rollers completely off the winch, along with some other pieces and chunks. Scared the crap outta me. The cable had several broken strands also so I'm just going to replace the whole thing. I'll mount it a little closer to center to try to get it to wind the cable correctly.
I hope I don't have to buy a new winch every 10 loads, that works out to about $40 per use.:lol